My book club won’t meet again until after the holidays.
When I belonged to other groups, I didn’t mind taking a break.
Not this time.
I’m going to miss getting together with the Word Witches’ Book Coven in December.
So, what makes this group something I look forward to every month?
Here’s the reasons why I love my current book club.
· The book is the focus:
Our group meets in a local bookstore, which is the perfect setting. There are no big meals, no glasses of wine, nothing to distract us from the task at hand: talking about the book. I’ve been part of neighborhood book clubs where the meeting was devoted to socializing and sharing gossip.
And there were times I was pretty sure I was the only one who read the book!
Don’t get me wrong. I like social get-togethers. They have their time and place. But for me, a book club’s primary focus should be on the book.
· We choose the books we want to read, instead of using other people’s lists.
Book of the Month, Read with Jenna, Reese’s book club, Oprah’s book club…there are no shortages of places that will recommend titles you should be reading. And while these places can be good resources, they tend to recommend a certain kind of book. A book that might feel more like homework than something I look forward to reading. Our group makes up our own list of books, and we vote on which ones we’d like to read. It’s a nice, democratic process. No single person (or type of book) dominates. Mind you, the system isn’t foolproof. The group has selected books that were a struggle for me to finish. But I’ve never regretted chugging through a less than inspiring book.
That’s because…
· People feel free to speak up if they don’t like a book.
If you ever belonged to a book club, you can picture the scene. Everyone arranged in a semi-circle, books resting on laps, when the inevitable question comes up. “So, what did everyone think of the book?” Strained silence, followed by throat clearing and nervous glances at the other members.
I don’t want to insult anyone, you think, but that book really sucked.
That’s what I like about my group. There is little hesitation. If we didn’t like the book, we speak up. If the book was confusing (or infuriating), we speak up. Talking about books is a lot like sharing stories about a vacation or a hiking trip gone bad. Sometimes, the books that don’t work for us are more interesting to discuss than the ones that do. There is more meat on the bone for us to chew on.
I mean, how many times can you say that a book was excellent before you run out of things to say?
· The group provides me with valuable insight as a writer
Hearing people discuss what worked and didn’t work in a story is also crucial to my own development as a writer. I have gone to conferences and gotten advice from professionals. I know the dangers writers can face. For example, a common problem is a story that starts out strong but peters out at the end. This is known as the third act problem.
But it’s one thing to be told. It’s a completely different experience to see the flaws ‘out in the wild’ and discuss it with my fellow readers. I think it’s made me more sensitive to spotting problems in my own work and making sure I do everything I can to correct it.
Of course, what you’re looking for in a book club might differ.
I’d love to hear what attracts you to a club (or doesn’t) and the books you like to read.
Maybe I’ll even devote a future blog to your responses!
Until then, here’s a peek at some of the books my group has read.
Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir
Six Wakes by Mur Lafferty
The Bog Wife by Kay Chronister
A Dowry of Blood by S.T. Gibson
Replaceable You by Mary Roach
The Dead Take the A Train by Cassandra Kaw and Richard Kadrey
Lock In by John Scalzi
What Moves the Dead by TK Kingfisher
Starving Saints by Caitlin Starling
The Ministry of Time by Kalian Bradley
The Annual Migration of Clouds by Premee Mohamed